Balancing MarketPart 5 of 10

Synchronized Frequency Restoration Reserve (S-FRR) in Japan

The LFC-Equivalent Product and Why It Is Last to Go Cross-Regional

Part 5 of 10 in Balancing Market and Co-Optimization Market

Synchronized Frequency Restoration Reserve (S-FRR) in Japan: The LFC-Equivalent Product and Why It Is Last to Go Cross-Regional

Role of S-FRR

Synchronized Frequency Restoration Reserve (S-FRR; secondary balancing capacity (1)) is one of the five products of the Supply and Demand Balancing Market (balancing market; the market in which general transmission and distribution companies, or GT&D companies, procure balancing capacity; see article 1). Trading began in April 2024.

S-FRR is balancing capacity for frequency control against the “short-period component,” demand fluctuation of a few minutes to around ten-plus minutes.

Demand fluctuation is divided by period into “very-short-period,” “short-period” and “long-period” components. Of these, the short-period component has been handled by load frequency control (LFC). S-FRR was designed as a product equivalent to this frequency control function provided by LFC. LFC is a function in which each area’s central load dispatching center (the GT&D company’s control room) calculates the adjustment needed to bring frequency back to the reference value (50 Hz or 60 Hz) and sends control signals to generators (article 2).

Demand changing from moment to moment, broken down into very-short-, short- and long-period components
Figure 1: Demand changing from moment to moment, broken down into very-short-, short- and long-period components
LFC as one of generators' frequency control functions
Figure 2: LFC as one of generators' frequency control functions

Role in Normal Conditions (Intra-Period Fluctuation of Demand and Renewables)

Actual demand and renewable output change from moment to moment. Even if forecast and actual values match as 30-minute averages, small fluctuations occur over periods shorter than 30 minutes.

This is called “intra-period fluctuation.” S-FRR is responsible for adjusting the short-period component of this fluctuation.

Frequency Containment Reserve (FCR; primary balancing capacity) measures frequency where the facility is located and responds by itself (local control). S-FRR, by contrast, follows the LFC signal (a control signal for returning to the reference frequency) sent from the GT&D company’s central dispatching system at a remote location.

Role in Contingencies

A contingency here means a generator stopping unexpectedly because of a fault or other trouble (generator trip). When a generator trip occurs, supply capacity drops suddenly and frequency falls, which could lead to a large-scale blackout. To prevent this, the lost supply capacity must be made up immediately with balancing capacity.

When frequency drops because of a generator trip, S-FRR raises its output based on the LFC signal sent from the central dispatching system and helps restore the reference frequency.

Generator trip as an event handled by balancing capacity
Figure 3: Generator trip as an event handled by balancing capacity

Product Requirements

The main requirements of S-FRR are as follows (Electric Power Reserve eXchange (EPRX), product requirements, 6th edition, March 13, 2026).

Item Requirement
Instruction and control Online (LFC signal)
Communication line Dedicated communication line only
Response time Within 5 minutes
Duration 30 minutes
Synchronization Required (the resource must be connected to the grid during the time slots it provides)
Instruction interval 0.5 to several tens of seconds
Monitoring interval About 1 to 5 seconds
Upper limit of available reserve capacity The amount by which output can be changed within 5 minutes (the LFC range based on equipment performance is the upper limit)
Bidding time unit and minimum bid 30 minutes, 1 MW

In normal conditions, S-FRR adjusts the difference between demand and supply in each area, which changes on the order of seconds. After receiving the LFC signal sent from the central dispatching system every few seconds, it must deliver output as quickly as possible. In practice, output appears after a certain time (response delay) from receipt of the signal. This response delay is set as a technical requirement (Organization for Cross-regional Coordination of Transmission Operators, JAPAN (OCCTO), Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 28th meeting, Material 3-3, p.21).

Resources planning to participate are checked in a pre-qualification review to confirm that the responses required in normal conditions and in contingencies meet the requirements.

Technical requirements for S-FRR: image of a response following the LFC signal (response delay and tracking of instructions)
Figure 4: Technical requirements for S-FRR: image of a response following the LFC signal (response delay and tracking of instructions)
Pre-qualification review for S-FRR: review items (tracking of instructions, response delay, response time, duration) and an image of the simulated LFC signal
Figure 5: Pre-qualification review for S-FRR: review items (tracking of instructions, response delay, response time, duration) and an image of the simulated LFC signal

How the Requirement Is Set

Approach at the Design Stage

The S-FRR requirement was designed as the sum of the requirement for normal conditions and the requirement for contingencies (OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 14th meeting, Material 2).

S-FRR = requirement for normal conditions + requirement for contingencies

  • Requirement for normal conditions: For 1- to 10-second measurement data of residual demand (demand minus renewables), the 3σ-equivalent value of the swing obtained by subtracting the “30-minute-period component” from the “10-minute-period component”
  • Requirement for contingencies: For each synchronous system at 50 Hz and at 60 Hz, the capacity of the largest single generating unit, allocated in proportion to each area’s system capacity

The 3σ-equivalent value is a statistically processed maximum. Specifically, it is the 99.87th percentile (if there are 10,000 data points, the 9,987th value from the smallest).

Requirement for Normal Conditions

In normal conditions, S-FRR adjusts the short-period component of demand. To do this, enough adjustment must be secured against the swing of the short-period component. The 3σ-equivalent value of this swing was set as the S-FRR requirement for normal conditions.

Requirement for Contingencies

When a generator trip occurs, the GT&D company uses the balancing capacity it has secured to contain the frequency drop and bring frequency back to the reference value.

FCR responds immediately after a generator trip, but because it can only continue for a short time, balancing capacity must then be handed over to S-FRR and then to Replacement Reserve (RR; tertiary balancing capacity (1)). So that this hand-over is possible, it was decided to secure the same contingency requirement for FCR, S-FRR and RR.

Frequency Restoration Reserve (FRR; secondary balancing capacity (2)) does not have to be synchronized to the grid. Because it cannot respond if a contingency occurs while it is not synchronized, the rule is that S-FRR, which is always synchronized and has a short instruction interval, is secured first as secondary balancing capacity for contingencies.

The largest generator trip to be covered is assumed to be the capacity of the largest single generating unit at 50 Hz and at 60 Hz respectively. It was therefore decided to calculate the contingency requirement (common to FCR, S-FRR and RR) as that capacity allocated in proportion to each area’s system capacity.

Frequency recovery and the hand-over among FCR, S-FRR and RR at a generator trip
Figure 6: Frequency recovery and the hand-over among FCR, S-FRR and RR at a generator trip
Requirement for generator trips in contingencies: allocation of the largest single generating unit
Figure 7: Requirement for generator trips in contingencies: allocation of the largest single generating unit

Trial Calculation at the Design Stage

In the 2019 trial calculation at the design stage, the S-FRR requirement in the TEPCO Power Grid area was a little under 2% of each month’s H3 demand (for each month, the average of the three highest daily peak demands) (14th meeting, Material 2, slide 63, PDF page 64). This was a trial calculation at the time based on week-ahead trading and 3-hour blocks, and differs from today’s procurement volume.

Trial calculation of S-FRR for the TEPCO Power Grid area (2019 trial calculation, as a ratio to H3 demand)
Figure 8: Trial calculation of S-FRR for the TEPCO Power Grid area (2019 trial calculation, as a ratio to H3 demand)

Today: Requirement at 3σ, Market Procurement up to 1σ

From FY2026 (April 2026–March 2027), the upper limit of the volume procured in the market was aligned to the 1σ-equivalent value. In Japan, the fiscal year runs from April to March. The S-FRR requirement remains at the 3σ-equivalent. The market procures up to the 1σ-equivalent value, and the remaining “3σ−1σ” is secured through spare-capacity utilization contracts (contracts under which the GT&D company uses the spare capacity of resources already running) (OCCTO, Study Committee on Regulating and Marginal Supply Capability and Long-Term Supply–Demand Balance Evaluation, 117th meeting, Material 4, p.74).

For delivery from April 26, 2025, the expected effect of EPPS has been deducted from the contingency requirement in areas that were ready. EPPS is a function of the frequency converters that link 50 Hz and 60 Hz. When frequency falls, it instantly sends power from the healthy area to the faulted area (same, pp.61–62).

Trading Mechanism

Item Up to delivery on March 13, 2026 From delivery on March 14, 2026
Trading timing Week-ahead (bids accepted from Monday 14:00 to Tuesday 14:00 of the previous week, cleared by Tuesday 15:00) Day-ahead (bids accepted from 11:30 to 14:00, cleared by 15:00)
Bidding time unit 3-hour blocks 30 minutes
Price cap ¥19.51/ΔkW per 30 minutes ¥15/ΔkW per 30 minutes (¥10 for delivery from September 1, 2026)

On S-FRR after the move to day-ahead trading, OCCTO reported the following (Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 61st meeting, Material 2, pp.13–14).

  • The procurement volume changed from the 3σ-equivalent to the 1σ-equivalent. On the other hand, the deduction of unoffered headroom ended, and negotiated contracts for pumped storage were forgone or not concluded in the Hokkaido and Tokyo areas. As a result, the procurement volume increased after the move to day-ahead trading.
  • National bid volumes increased, but bid volumes fell in some areas, causing undersubscription, and the shortfall rate rose. In the Kansai area, bid volumes themselves fell, and shortfall rates rose in the Kansai and Hokuriku areas.

For the first half of FY2026 (up to August 31), OCCTO reported that national bid volumes increased but the shortfall rate remained high. By area, following Hokkaido, Chugoku, Shikoku and Kyushu, shortfall rates also improved in the Chubu and Tokyo areas, while shortfall rates remained high in the Tohoku, Hokuriku and Kansai areas (Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 63rd meeting, Material 4, pp.15–16).

S-FRR procurement volume, bid volume and shortfall rate, April to August 2026
Figure 9: S-FRR procurement volume, bid volume and shortfall rate, April to August 2026

Why Cross-Regional Procurement Comes Last

S-FRR is the only one of the five products procured only within each area. The other products already use “cross-regional procurement,” in which several areas procure jointly (article 1).

Cross-regional procurement of S-FRR comes last because it is a product driven by the LFC signal. Each area’s central load dispatching center issues the LFC signal for its own area. To use resources in other areas as S-FRR, “cross-regional operation,” in which LFC is operated across areas, must come first.

Cross-regional procurement has been targeted from FY2027, on the premise that cross-regional operation of S-FRR by the GT&D companies can be achieved (Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 57th meeting, Material 5, p.3 and p.27).

Cross-regional operation (cross-regional LFC) was prepared by adding functions to the existing cross-regional balancing system. After trial operation, it formally started in the eastern region (Tohoku and Tokyo areas) on January 30, 2026, and in the central and western region (Chubu, Hokuriku, Kansai, Chugoku, Shikoku and Kyushu areas) on April 28, 2026. OCCTO assessed that frequency fluctuations were at a similar level before and after the switch, and that the effect of supply-demand deviations offsetting each other between areas reduced the amount of LFC action and the kWh cost of balancing capacity. On that basis, at the 63rd meeting of the Subcommittee on the Balancing Market on September 15, 2026, it presented a proposal to implement cross-regional procurement of S-FRR from FY2027, as originally planned (63rd meeting, Material 2, p.2, p.12, p.14, p.24 and p.29).

Product introduction schedule of the balancing market, showing that only S-FRR is procured within each area and that cross-regional procurement is targeted from FY2027
Figure 10: Product introduction schedule of the balancing market, showing that only S-FRR is procured within each area and that cross-regional procurement is targeted from FY2027
Schedule from trial operation to formal operation of cross-regional LFC (start in the eastern region, and start in the central and western region)
Figure 11: Schedule from trial operation to formal operation of cross-regional LFC (start in the eastern region, and start in the central and western region)

Summary

S-FRR was designed as a product equivalent to the frequency control function of load frequency control (LFC), and trading began in April 2024.

In normal conditions, it adjusts the short-period component of demand, and a sufficient volume is needed against the swing of the short-period component. In contingencies, it takes over the role from FCR, which responds immediately after a generator trip but has a short duration.

From March 2026, it moved to day-ahead trading in 30-minute units, market procurement was limited to the 1σ-equivalent value, and the price cap became ¥10/ΔkW per 30 minutes from September 2026. Cross-regional operation of LFC started by April 2026, and a proposal has been presented to implement cross-regional procurement from FY2027.

This article is based on published materials from the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry and its Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, the Electricity and Gas Market Surveillance Commission, the Organization for Cross-regional Coordination of Transmission Operators (OCCTO) and other sources. The English translations of figures are by ENERGY ADVISOR and are not official translations. When using this information for decisions, please check the original sources. When we find an error, we correct the article and note the date of the correction.

Sources

  • Electric Power Reserve eXchange (EPRX), “Product Requirements and Trading Schedule of the Supply and Demand Balancing Market (6th edition)” (in Japanese), p.2 and p.3, March 13, 2026. https://www.eprx.or.jp/outline/docs/shouhin_ver.6_20260313.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 14th meeting, Material 2, “Approach to the Requirements for FCR to RR” (in Japanese), slide numbers 13, 14, 25, 28, 33 and 63 (PDF pages 14, 15, 26, 29, 34 and 64), November 5, 2019. https://www.occto.or.jp/iinkai/chouseiryoku/jukyuchousei/2019/files/jukyu_shijyo_14_02r.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 1st meeting, Material 4, “ΔkW Traded in the Balancing Market” (in Japanese), p.10 (image of balancing capacity response and hand-over at a generator trip), February 23, 2018. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/chouseiryoku/jukyuchousei/2017/files/jukyu_shijo_01_04.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 28th meeting, Material 3-3 (technical requirements and pre-qualification review for S-FRR) (in Japanese), p.21 and p.28, February 24, 2022. https://www.occto.or.jp/iinkai/chouseiryoku/jukyuchousei/2021/files/jukyu_shijyo_28_03_03.pdf
  • OCCTO, Study Committee on Regulating and Marginal Supply Capability and Long-Term Supply–Demand Balance Evaluation, 117th meeting, Material 4, “Status of Discussions in the Subcommittee on the Balancing Market (FY2025 Report)” (in Japanese), pp.61–62 and p.74, March 16, 2026. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/chousei_117_04.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 57th meeting, Material 5, “Direction and Summary of Discussions in the Subcommittee on the Balancing Market (Results for the First Half of FY2025 and Plans for the Second Half of FY2025)” (in Japanese), p.3 and p.27, September 26, 2025. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/chouseiryoku/jukyuchousei/2025/files/jukyu_shijyo_57_05.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 61st meeting, Material 2, “Trading Status of the Balancing Market” (in Japanese), pp.13–14, June 9, 2026. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/jukyuchousei/61/jukyu_shijyo_61_02.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 63rd meeting, Material 2, “Cross-Regional Operation and Cross-Regional Procurement of S-FRR” (in Japanese), p.2, p.12, p.14, p.24 and p.29, September 15, 2026. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/jukyuchousei/63/jukyu_shijyo_63_02.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 63rd meeting, Material 4, “Direction and Summary of Discussions in the Subcommittee on the Balancing Market (Results for the First Half of FY2026 and Plans for the Second Half of FY2026 Onward)” (in Japanese), p.3 and pp.15–16, September 15, 2026. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/jukyuchousei/63/jukyu_shijyo_63_04.pdf
  • OCCTO, Subcommittee on the Balancing Market, 62nd meeting, Material 2, “Results of Fact-Finding Surveys on the Balancing Market” (in Japanese), pp.15–16, July 31, 2026. https://www.occto.or.jp/assets/iinkai/jukyuchousei/62/jukyu_shijyo_62_02.pdf